🐐 Dam, Bottle, or Hybrid! What would you pick for your Goat Kids?

When it comes to raising goat kids, there are basically three parenting styles:

• Dam raising – Let mama do her thing while you cheer her on from the sidelines.

• Bottle raising – You become “goat parent of the year,” complete with sleepless nights, spilled milk, and kids that think you’re their personal Uber Eats.

• Hybrid raising – Tag-team parenting: a little bit mama, a little bit you. Basically co-parenting… goat edition.

So which way is better? Let’s take a little look.

🐐 Dam Raising (a.k.a. “Go Ask Your Mother”)
Mama goat handles parenting while you play the supportive role—like a coach clapping on the sidelines with snacks.
Pros:

• Low-maintenance for you – No middle-of-the-night feedings. The doe’s got this covered.

• Built-in immunity – Kids get colostrum and antibodies straight from mom. Think of it as goat multivitamins… with superpowers.

• Social skills 101 – Kids learn how to be goats from other goats. Headbutting, hay stealing, standing on things they shouldn’t—you name it.

• All-you-can-eat milk buffet – No bottles, no schedules, just unlimited milk on tap.

Cons:

• Not-so-cuddly kids – These babies bond with Mama, and while they can be friendly, it can take a lot of time. You’ll be the “background character” in their life story.

* Weaning = goat soap opera – loud crying, headbutting, dramatic standoffs. Basically, a goat telenovela.

• Disease roulette – Mama and herd members can pass on germs. Welcome to “Goat Kindergarten: Germ Sharing Edition.” ( now honestly I don’t know really if this is a con it can go bad but heard immunity can be a great thing and of course everyone has their own opinion about this some do vaccinations while other like myself do more of a Holistic way. My advice is to do lots and lots of research and find what you want to do )

• Udder favoritism – Some kids only nurse on one side. Translation: uneven udders and one very cranky mama. If this happens, you will need to milk out the side that the kid is not nursing on.

🍼 Bottle Raising (a.k.a. “Full-Time Goat Nanny”)

You’re officially goat mom (or dad). Congratulations—you now run a 24/7 goat daycare. Snacks included.

Pros:
• Instant besties – Bottle babies will adore you. Forget dogs—these goats will climb in your lap, follow you everywhere, and cry if you shut the bathroom door.

• Udder TLC – The doe’s udder stays balanced and healthy because you’re managing all the feedings.

• Better disease control – You’re the milk manager, so you can dodge certain health risks.

• Early weaning options – Want to sell kids earlier? Bottle babies make that easier.

Cons:

• You’re now the cafeteria worker – Feedings are on a strict schedule. Kiss your free mornings goodbye.

• Expensive babies –  While  now you will be going through more milk, you will have to choose if you are going with milk replacer  or whole milk a.k.a red cap (depending on where you live for the color of the cap).  You’ll swear the kids are drinking more than you budgeted for. (Spoiler: they are.)

• Goat identity crisis – Bottle babies sometimes grow up thinking they’re human. Cute… until one tries to join you on the couch. ( Is that really a con? 🤔 )

• Stage-five clingers – Forget personal space. You now have goat shadows, and yes—they will scream if you leave them for five minutes.

🐐🍼 Hybrid Raising (a.k.a. “Tag-Team Parenting”)

Mama does most of the work, but you step in with bottles when needed. Think of it like joint custody.

Pros:

• Best of both worlds – Kids still learn goat manners from mom and  bond with you. They get herd training from mama and extra snacks from you—basically, jackpot kids.

• Backup plan – If mama’s low on milk or juggling triplets, you roll in like the substitute teacher who actually brings candy.

• Less work than full bottle feeding – You’re not chained to a strict schedule; just filling in the gaps.

Cons:

• Still some work – You can’t fully escape. Monitoring nursing, balancing bottles, and explaining why the goat kids eat better than your family is all part of the fun.

• Goat confusion – Kids may look at you and think, “Wait… are you the snack bar or the babysitter?”

• Attachment shuffle – The kids get clingy with mom and you, so now you both get tackled at feeding time like a goat mosh pit.

🏆 The Final Verdict!   So… who wins the goat-parenting trophy?

• What ever way works best for you! For me, I love the hybrid way.   While I don’t love washing bottles, I do enjoy seeing those little milk faces. Having them run towards you is the cutes thing. Receiving the little kid cuddles just warms my heart.
• Being able to help the doe out as every mother knows that little break is what keeps us sane!

Thank you for reading my blog. Please follow, like, share!

#mjbackyardingwithkids #homesteading #goats #wednesday #loveofgoats #whatwouldyoupick #countryliving #GoatLove #bottle #feedings #life